Revising history has never been as much fun as this ridiculous reimagining from Cole Escola featuring Mary Todd Lincoln in the days before her husband’s assassination. The huge Broadway hit is a hoot – who knew the president’s wife used to be a showgirl? The former cabaret star is now a frustrated first lady and, to distract her Abe hires an actor to give her drama lessons. A romance starts, but Mary loses her lover. And her mind. Actually, that went long ago.
Mary is a monster, albeit an appealingly vivid one. Her flaws make her sympathetic and the lack of self-pity is refreshing but, make no mistake, she is every vice combined. This is a tremendous role that exercises every comedic skill. For this London premiere, Mason Alexander Park makes the most of Mary, refusing to hold back and getting to show off their voice in the startling – hilarious – finale.
While Escola has written a great star vehicle, smaller roles, such as Mary’s chaperone or her husband’s assistant, allow Kate O’Donnell and Oliver Stockley to also shine. The always excellent Giles Terera plays Lincoln and, while the play just calls him ‘Mary’s Husband’, he gets time in the spotlight. Terera scores a lot of laughs at Lincoln’s guilt about being gay – it really is a giggle. Finally, to avoid spoilers, let’s just say there’s a lot going on with that acting tutor. Dino Fetscher is perfectly cast and does a great job.
A lot of the jokes come from the historical figures swearing or having sex – the play is very rude. There are also plenty of gags about alcoholism and depression… and how ignorant Mary is. It’s all rather childish and stupid, so lots of it probably shouldn’t be funny. And I cannot understand why referring to a portrait of George Washington as her mother works so well. It really is a laugh a minute.
The brilliantly exaggerated movements in director Sam Pinkleton’s production are part of the superb physical comedy. The lighting design from Cha See and costumes from Holly Pierson excel at aiding the humour. Mary’s hoop skirt deserves its own round of applause.
The theatre itself is a big joke, too. And there’s a challenge here. Leaning into ‘low’ comedy and cabaret, it could be tempting to dismiss the play, especially with its sketch-like structure. But the short scenes end with plenty of punchlines that surprise and have an emotional edge. The action builds nicely to the night of Lincoln’s death – in a theatre, of course. And if you’ve never wondered who shot who, then perhaps you should?
Until 25 April 2025
Photo by Manuel Harlan







