Hello and welcome to The Shylock Project, a company from Syracuse New York, who are visiting London for two weeks. Their piece about Edgar Allan Poe is an appealing oddity. There are questions and flaws around the staging. But writers Matt Chiorini and Greg Giovanini have smart ideas and the show is full of invention.
Combining Poe’s biography with his stories and poems means that there is a lot going on. The structure is sound and, as directors, Chiorini and Giovanini handle the action well. There’s a temptation to prefer just an adaptation of Poe’s tales (or even the well-managed mash-up we have here). But the biography is meaty. We get two sides of the man – his genius and his tragedy – and the investigation offers insight. And there’s a neat touch, indicative of a playful humour underlying the show, to remind us that Poe is “sus”.
Much rests on having two people perform as Poe, so that he can comment on his writing while also being placed in the action of his own tales. Sammy Overton and Morgan Smith take the role and tackle the idea well. I enjoyed ticking off elements in the stories: mysterious summons, haunted house, unreliable narrator and buried treasure. Support comes from Kilian Crowley, Maya June Dwyer and Moxie Dwyer who add mania, melodrama, hysteria and horror as and when required.
Edgar in the Red Room is fun, but there are flaws. While the movement work is strong, special praise for Dwyer here, it is often fussy and comedic touches are overused. A bigger problem comes with the music. Billed as a ‘Burial Chamber Musical’ (nice) the songs are not strong and add so much less than intended they become uncomfortable. Fear not, the projections and shadow play on offer are excellent and save the day. A lo-fi approach like this, illustrating creativity so literally, is often a winner. The powerful imagery goes a long way to dispel drawbacks.
Until 14 February 2026
Photo by Greg Giovanini